Sec 2, Unit 8, The Necklace, SB page 48: Her husband suggests that she borrow valuable jewellery from her friend. (subjunctive) (1) Her husband suggests that she borrow valuable jewellery from her friend. (=should borrow=borrows) (2) It's essential that every child have the same educational opportunities. (=should have=has) (3) The judge recommended that the man remain in prison for 30 years. (=should remain=remained) Can I teach it like that?
don’t exactly understand your question. In particular, I’m not sure if your use of the equal sign (=) is meant to say that these phrases are equal, or if you’re trying to separate choices in a multiple choice question.
The verb borrow in sentence (1), have in (2), and remain in (3) are all mandative subjunctives. This is a construction that calls for a particular action.
Mandatives come after verbs such as advise, ask, beg, demand, desire, direct, insist, move, order, propose, recommend, request, require, stipulate, suggest, urge; after adjectives such as essential, important, necessary, vital; and after conjunctions such as in order that and on condition that.
The mandative subjunctive is used regularly in North America, Australia, and New Zealand. In British English, it tends to be replaced by should, but there are signs that the mandative subjunctive is coming back into use. (The Cambridge Guide to English Usage)
So in the sentences you have above, two answers are possible in each: (1) borrow or should borrow (2) have or should have (3) remain or should remain
So how do you want to teach it? That part of your question is not clear to me
Sec 2, Unit 8, The Necklace, SB page 48: Her husband suggests that she borrow valuable jewellery from her friend. (subjunctive) (1) Her husband suggests that she borrow valuable jewellery from her friend. (=should borrow=borrows) (2) It's essential that every child have the same educational opportunities. (=should have=has) (3) The judge recommended that the man remain in prison for 30 years. (=should remain=remained) Can I teach it like that?
ردحذفdon’t exactly understand your question. In particular, I’m not sure if your use of the equal sign (=) is meant to say that these phrases are equal, or if you’re trying to separate choices in a multiple choice question.
ردحذفThe verb borrow in sentence (1), have in (2), and remain in (3) are all mandative subjunctives. This is a construction that calls for a particular action.
Mandatives come after verbs such as advise, ask, beg, demand, desire, direct, insist, move, order, propose, recommend, request, require, stipulate, suggest, urge; after adjectives such as essential, important, necessary, vital; and after conjunctions such as in order that and on condition that.
The mandative subjunctive is used regularly in North America, Australia, and New Zealand. In British English, it tends to be replaced by should, but there are signs that the mandative subjunctive is coming back into use. (The Cambridge Guide to English Usage)
So in the sentences you have above, two answers are possible in each:
(1) borrow or should borrow
(2) have or should have
(3) remain or should remain
So how do you want to teach it? That part of your question is not clear to me